The published prices side by side
These are the figures each vendor prints, collected on our individual pricing pages. A blank means the vendor asks you to book a call. We build CaseAgent, so its row is included and labeled, and every other row is the vendor's own number.
| Tool | Published price | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Gavel Lite, Standard, Pro | $99, $250, $350 a month, or $83 to $290 billed yearly | Per account, $50 per extra builder |
| Gavel Exec | $160 a month or $1,740 a year | Per user, Word add-in |
| Paxton | $499 a month or $2,999 a year | Per user |
| GC AI | $500 a month | Per individual |
| Spellbook | Quote only | Per seat, renewal capped at 10% a year |
| Harvey | Quote only | Per seat |
| CaseAgent | $149 Solo, $399 up to 5 users, $899 up to 15 | Per firm, drafting included |
Two things are easy to miss. Gavel's lower tiers are priced per account, so a firm of three can share one. And the Word add-ins are per user, which is what makes them look cheap for one lawyer and expensive for ten.
The same tools at three firm sizes
The bill depends on how many people draft. This table prices one year, using the published per user rates and the lowest published tier of each model. It leaves out the quote only tools because there is no number to multiply.
| Drafting lawyers | Gavel Exec, $1,740 a year each | Paxton, $2,999 a year each | CaseAgent, per firm |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $1,740 | $2,999 | $1,788 ($149 a month) |
| 4 | $6,960 | $11,996 | $4,788 ($399 a month) |
| 12 | $20,880 | $35,988 | $10,788 ($899 a month) |
For a single lawyer the three are close. The gap opens at four drafters and widens from there, because the flat plan stops growing while the per seat tools keep multiplying. The comparison is on price only. A Word contract add-in and a case file agent do different jobs, which the next section sorts out.
Which kind of drafting do you actually buy
Three products hide behind the phrase. Contract drafting and review tools such as Spellbook and Gavel Exec work inside Word on agreements, with clause libraries and redlines. Template and workflow builders such as Gavel's account tiers turn a form into a questionnaire you maintain. Case file agents such as CaseAgent write letters, discovery and summaries from the documents in a matter.
A transactional firm that drafts the same agreements all week belongs in the first or second group. A plaintiff or litigation firm whose drafts depend on a police report, medical records and an order belongs in the third. Some firms need both and pay for both, which is a fair outcome as long as each tool is priced against the work it replaces. See legal document automation software for the template side and AI contract review for the Word side.
What is not in the price
- Review time. Every AI draft needs a lawyer to read it. The saving is in the first draft, not in the sign off. The duty of competence in Model Rule 1.1 stays with the lawyer.
- Renewal terms. Spellbook's terms cap annual increases at 10 percent and do not let you reduce seats during the term. Ask for the renewal clause before you sign a per seat contract.
- Setup work. Template tools cost hours of builder time per form. A case file agent needs the documents in the matter and nothing else.
- Citations. No drafting tool removes the need to check authority. Budget for your research database separately, as in what Westlaw costs per month.
How to decide in ten minutes
- Count the people who draft and the documents each writes a month.
- Mark each document type as repeat form, contract, or fact driven letter, discovery or motion.
- Price the repeat forms on a template tier and the contracts on a Word add-in, using the table above.
- Price the fact driven work on a flat plan. See CaseAgent pricing.
- Test one closed matter on the cheapest candidate before you commit to a year.
Frequently asked questions
How much does AI legal drafting software cost?
Published prices run from $83 a month per account billed yearly at Gavel Lite to $499 a month per user at Paxton, and Spellbook and Harvey publish no price at all. A flat firm plan such as CaseAgent at $149 a month for a solo or $399 for up to five users sits at the low end for a team.
Is AI legal drafting software priced per user?
Most of it is. Gavel Exec, Paxton, GC AI and Spellbook charge per seat, so the bill grows with every lawyer you add. Gavel Standard and Pro are priced per account with extra builders at $50 each. CaseAgent prices per firm, with a user cap on each plan rather than a per seat fee.
What is the cheapest way to draft legal documents with AI?
For one lawyer who drafts occasionally, a low per account tier is the cheapest. For a firm of three or more that drafts weekly, a flat firm plan usually wins because per seat tools multiply by headcount. Count your drafters and the documents each one writes a month before you compare.
Do drafting tools charge extra for each document?
The tools in this comparison do not charge per document. Deposition and demand letter services do, so a firm that buys drafts by the document should compare that fee against a subscription at its real monthly volume.
Can AI replace template based document automation?
Not for repeat forms. A template with fixed clauses is faster and more predictable for wills, engagement letters and standard agreements. AI drafting from the case file is stronger where the facts change in every matter, such as discovery, demand letters and motions.
To see the agent side of this comparison, read AI legal drafting software for small law firms or the guide to billing clients for AI tools.